OOP Time Turner

[Mark D.]

No: HPFGUIDX 68919

EXCEPT as in history time seems to be written by the victor. If you 
reread your PoA you'll realize Harry and Hermione went back in time 
to save Buckbeak, Sirius, and themselves! The deciding factor is 
that Harry remembers seeing himself.

My silly idea... Hermione as she falls before the dementors makes a 
subconcious decision to go back in time and save herself, after all 
she was wearing the timeturner around her neck at the time.

It's probably better that she doesn't have it anymore. I could 
picture Hermione in battle ala Bill & Ted's Adventure. "Oh here's LV 
and all his deatheaters! If only the OOP could come to my rescue! 
Wait a minute, I just need to remember to go back in time later and 
tell them to show up here in about 5 seconds! 3,2,1 Oh here they are!

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "sevenhundredandthirteen" 
<sevenhundredandthirteen at y...> wrote:
> dreambeliever001 wrote:
> 
> > In one of the rooms in MOM were a bunch of time turners.  It 
seems 
> > like Harry might of thought of getting one since he knew how to 
use 
> > them (PA)  Then he could of went back and saved Sirius.
> 
> Except that the almighty rule of Time Travel is *you* *can't* 
> *change* *time*. So, seeing as Sirius is already dead, no-one can 
go 
> back and change it. Just the same as no-one could've gone back in 
> time and saved Harry's parents from death. They were alread dead. 
> Time happens only once and continues to move forward- and Sirius 
died.
> 
> Besides, the cabinet of time-turners got smashed in the fighting, 
> didn't it? So, even if Harry *wanted* to go back in time to try to 
> save Sirius he couldn't have. Anyway, like I said- he couldn't 
have 
> saved him anyway because only *people* move backwards through time-
 
> time never moves backwards itself, so what happened happened once 
and 
> cannot be changed.
> 
> ~<(Laurasia)>~