I Corinthians 13--random thoughts

jdr0918 jdr0918 at hotmail.com
Thu Jul 10 21:01:23 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 69173

<<< "terryljames76" wrote:...I am not suggesting that JKR is drawing 
from the Bible for any of her work...Nor am I comparing any of JKR's 
characters to any Biblical characters...OK, Bible lesson over.  Feel 
free to pick it apart.>>>

The Sergeant Majorette says:

The Bible, baseball, soccer, boarding school, middle management, 
international politics, classical mythology; JKR is not drawing from 
any of these for her work. These are eternal verities that will 
influence the work of any author that lives in the world. You cannot, 
for example, write a realistic story involving teenage boys that does 
not involve team sports; you cannot write a story about teenage girls 
(that girls will read) that does not involve teenage boys. How we 
feel about Hermione is a function of how we dealt with the Hermione 
we knew (or were). Virtually everyone will be coming from some 
religious belief system or other.

Probably these kinds of long-form analyses tell us more about the 
analysts than they do about JKR and the Potterverse; as such, 
however, they are interesting and worthwhile reading.

--JDR





More information about the HPforGrownups archive