Dumbledore and Harry

karenlyall666 karen.lyall at blueyonder.co.uk
Thu Jul 10 23:21:49 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 69215

>From Michael:
> 
> This has been suggested before, but I don't think this is the case. 
Somewere 
> in SS (I think the 1st chapter) Dumbledore says that the Dursleys 
are his 
> only family. And I really don't see how Dumbledore could send Harry 
to the 
> Dursleys if he really were related to him. I mean, if the blood 
relation was 
> the force that kept Harry protected, woundn't Dumbledore's blood 
> relationship have counted? I already have a low opinion of 
Dumbledore for 
> sending Harry to live with the Dursleys and if it does turn out 
that he is 
> related to Harry, then in my opinion, he is worse than Snape.

I thought the blood protection thing had to be his mother's blood?

Which means feasably AD could be related on James' side of the family 
not Lily's...

By the way this is just me playing devils advocat, I personally agree 
with you and think that the Dursleys weren't so much 'the best of a 
bad lot' but the 'only lot'.  I don't think Harry and Dumbledore are 
blood relatives, I do think a nice connection would be AD being  
Godfather to one of Harry's grandparents - but that's just wishful 
thinking.

An image has just popped into my head though of AD and MMc in the 
road outside #4.  I don't remember the exact dialogue, but something 
like this..

MMc (Indignantly): "Harry Potter!  Live here?"
AD (his knowing smile, his hands hidden in the folds of his robe):
"They are his only living relatives," and added in an undertone just 
before he uncrosses all his fingers, "on his mother's side..."

Sorry only piece of fanfic I've ever written - but I thought it was 
funny and it's the kind of thing I'd expect from a man who's brother 
performs 'inappropriate' charms on goats...

Karen (who's lack of sleep is starting to show ever more obviously)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive