Dumbledore and Harry

C & K cmann1071 at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 10 22:56:12 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 69257


> Craig wrote:
> >
> >Could there be a possibility that Dumbeldore is related to Harry, 
on Jame's side of course.  We hear all about Lilys side of the family
> >but what about James side.  Could Dumbeldore be James dad.
> >Dumbledore is 150 years old so there could be a chance.
> >
> 
> From Michael:
> 
> This has been suggested before, but I don't think this is the 
case. Somewere in SS (I think the 1st chapter) Dumbledore says that 
the Dursleys are his only family. And I really don't see how 
Dumbledore could send Harry to the Dursleys if he really were related 
to him. I mean, if the blood relation was the force that kept Harry 
protected, woundn't Dumbledore's blood relationship have counted? I 
already have a low opinion of Dumbledore for sending Harry to live with 
the Dursleys and if it does turn out that he is related to Harry, then 
in my opinion, he is worse than Snape. >>>>>
 

ME:

It is always stated that Lily gave her life for Harry and it was her 
sacrifice that created that protection for Harry.  Maybe that 
protection wouldn't have worked if Harry wasn't with her side of the 
family. Not sure, just throwing out ideas. 

"Craig"






More information about the HPforGrownups archive