Hermione attempted murder!

[vecseytj]

No: HPFGUIDX 69282


> > --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, CareALotsClouds at a... wrote:
> > 
> > Isnt anyone else disturbed that Hermione sent herself, Harry and 
> > Umbridge into the forest knowing fully well that the centaurs would 
> > murder Umbridge and leave them?  Now I know they were in a tough 
> > situation but murder is inexcusible!

Me:  I have been reading this post for a while... and no one says
anything about the fact the Umbridge was about to do an unforgivable
curse on the kids so they would talk!  Umbridge was going to torture
these children until they talked!  With the same curse that put
Longbottoms parents in the Mental ward.  I think Hermione did what she
*HAD* to do to protect the "gang". 

> --- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "ellejir" <eberte at v...> wrote:
> I agree with Bill.  I do not think that Hermione was consciously 
> trying to kill Umbridge (although she *was* about to expell Hermione 
> and the gang...so if ever an arguement could be made!). 

ME:  And you must remember Hermione said in the very first book, "You
are going to get us killed, Or worse expelled!"  So death *IS* not as
scarry to Hermione as being expelled.  So I'm not at all suprised that
she would do everything in her power to get rid of Umbridge.  
GO HERMIONE!
TJ