Hermione attempted murder!

[darrin_burnett]

No: HPFGUIDX 69455

Carealot: 
> 

> WELL... whatever was gonna happen to the gang, having someone killed is 
just too far.  I also thought of JK not having Umbridge die in the hands of 
> Hermione, but if JK did let it happen, how would Hermione handle it when >
>she knew  exactly what she was doing? 

Once again, how can it be said that Hermione KNEW Umbridge was going to 
die, when Umbridge didn't die? 

There is simply no proof that Hermione wanted anything more than to keep 
Umbridge occupied while they escaped. 

And again, since Umbridge had a wand at their backs and was leaving them 
unarmed, even though Umbridge KNEW the forest was dangerous, and flat-
out said, "Sorry, Potter, the Ministry finds me more valuable than it finds you" I 
refuse to muster a smidgen of sympathy for Umbridge or outrage for 
Hermione.

And well, it's easy to say, "whatever was going to happen to the gang" isn't it? 

Well, tell you what. WHATEVER happened to Snape as a kid, doing what he 
does to the kids is just going too far. 

How's that?

Darrin