Why Hermoine trusts Snape
alicepmint
alicepmint at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 12 03:34:43 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 69616
Melpomene said:
> Here here! May we please move on! She not only got over it but got
> her teeth fixed to HER satisfaction behind her parents' back as
well.
> (Yes she'd have done that without the quip...okay okay.)
Me three. It just seems so out-of-character for Hermione when some
people kept grudging on what a poor fragile little typical girly girl
she was, like she's been shattered by one comment like looks is
everything to her, as if she drawn her self-esteem from that big
teeth of hers. As if she's eternally scar-for-life or something. I
know everyone project his/her own values and standard on the
readings, I always identified myself with Hermione, seeing duplicate
of the teenage self in her always. And I know perfectly well Hermione
is A LOT more stronger than what some whiny people here made her out
of (frankly I'm slightly annoyed by how everyone underestimate her
character by OVER-emphasized how TRAUMATIC this one incident is...to
the point I just have to roll my eye, big deal! Hermione's a big
strong girl!). She have a brilliant clear, logical mind, who always
put reasons over emotions. Especially this one incident motivated her
to finally actually DO something about her teeth for good once and
for all! She got it fixed, tackling that one weak spot so no one
could pick on that anymore. She dealt with it. She moved on,
Gryfinddor style! And there's NOT one single canon evidence ever
showed that she was bothered by this incident one bit later. She's
still the same proud strong girl we known of. She talked of Snape in
the same manner she always does. She's comfortable with her image and
knowledge as a person. I was proud of her. She got over it, and
obviously forgave (ignore is the better word) Snape. She's cool about
it, so yes can we move on and stopped over-exaggerage and single-out
this one incident to shame Hermione as in she's some fragile insecure
poor little girl please?
Alice
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive