Why Hermoine trusts Snape
Tamara
buffyeton at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 12 05:18:13 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 69650
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "alicepmint" <alicepmint at y...>
wrote:
> Melpomene said:
> > Here here! May we please move on! She not only got over it but
got
> > her teeth fixed to HER satisfaction behind her parents' back as
> well.
> > (Yes she'd have done that without the quip...okay okay.)
>
> Me three. It just seems so out-of-character for Hermione when some
> people kept grudging on what a poor fragile little typical girly
girl
> she was, like she's been shattered by one comment like looks is
> everything to her, as if she drawn her self-esteem from that big
> teeth of hers. As if she's eternally scar-for-life or something. I
> know everyone project his/her own values and standard on the
> readings, I always identified myself with Hermione, seeing
duplicate
> of the teenage self in her always. And I know perfectly well
Hermione
> is A LOT more stronger than what some whiny people here made her
out
> of (frankly I'm slightly annoyed by how everyone underestimate her
> character by OVER-emphasized how TRAUMATIC this one incident
is...to
> the point I just have to roll my eye, big deal! Hermione's a big
> strong girl!). She have a brilliant clear, logical mind, who always
> put reasons over emotions. Especially this one incident motivated
her
> to finally actually DO something about her teeth for good once and
> for all! She got it fixed, tackling that one weak spot so no one
> could pick on that anymore. She dealt with it. She moved on,
> Gryfinddor style! And there's NOT one single canon evidence ever
> showed that she was bothered by this incident one bit later. She's
> still the same proud strong girl we known of. She talked of Snape
in
> the same manner she always does. She's comfortable with her image
and
> knowledge as a person. I was proud of her. She got over it, and
> obviously forgave (ignore is the better word) Snape. She's cool
about
> it, so yes can we move on and stopped over-exaggerage and single-
out
> this one incident to shame Hermione as in she's some fragile
insecure
> poor little girl please?
>
> Alice
It seems quite simple to me: Hermione trusts Snape because, from what
she can tell, Dumbledore trusts Snape.
Tamara
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive