Questions about the Original Order, DEs, etc.

quigonginger quigonginger at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 12 15:50:35 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 69710

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "greatlit2003" <hieya at h...> 
wrote:
snippalot> 
> I want to know why DD waited so long to start the original Order. 
> Assuming that James and Lily started Hogwarts in 1971, graduated in 
> 1978 (this follows JKR's comment about Snape being 35 or 36 around 
> GoF), V-mort was in power from 1970-1981. If there was an Order 
> before James and Lily joined, why didn't Moody show a photograph of 
> that? Throughout OOP, there are references to only one other Order, 
> the one that the Potters were in.
> 
> Moody showed Harry a photo of the Original Order, and pointed out 
who 
> had died. If you follow the above timeline, the photo was taken 
> between 1978-1980. Once again, why so many deaths in that 
particular 
> time period? Could this be the reason why Snape hates Harry so 
much? 
> Was there a whole war over Harry, with a lot of casaulties?
> snipsomemore

Ginger (me) has a thought:

Moody showed Harry a picture circa 1978-80.  V was in power from 1970-
1981.  Maybe that picture was just one of many he pulled out to show 
Harry as it had his parents in it.  There may have been others from 
previous years before the Potters joined, but those pictures wouldn't 
have had the personal significance.  

I think Moody was showing it to him to show that his parents were 
heros in the last VW, and that when he threw in all the details about 
half the people dying, Harry took it the wrong way, which Harry was 
prone to do in OoP.

Ginger, who is currently bothered by a mosquito bite deep in her ear.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive