Tonks.....??? What if.....

[danielmorgan322]

No: HPFGUIDX 69933

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "oh have faith" 
<rshuson80 at y...> wrote:
>  "lynnfaragher78" wrote:
> > 
> > 
> > Just wondering something......
> > 
> > Seeing that Tonks can change her apperance.....what if she had 
> > changed herself in to DU (aka the toad).....or the other way 
> > around.... I don't remember in the book if they were ever in the 
> >same place at 
> > the same time......  also Tonks could change into someone like 
> >Dumbledor to throw off LV and the DE....that could be intresting
> 
> Then Faiths Girl said:
> 
> Mm, it's an interesting ability.  It's got me thinking whether we 
> may have actually seen Tonks in the books before, under the guise 
of 
> someone else?  
> 
> Faith's Girl

Now me:

I dont believe for a second that Tonks is DU. Or has been 
impersonating her. However JKR has done stranger things...

The first time i heard Tonks tell Harry that she was a Metamorphagus 
I thought "hmm... sounds a bit fishy to me" I dont trust Tonks at 
all.

I think if she isn't already spying on the Order then she will at 
some point in the next two books. 

Does anyone get the feelin she's untrustworthy or is she just a " 
Red hearing" placed by JKR to send us down the wrong path?

Thoughts people

Morgan

P.S:

I keep hearing people saying that,"JKR never puts in details for 
details sake, they always mean something" (and words to a similar 
effect) how can we know wether or not everything is important if 
there are still two books to come? Grrr.