Remus and Tonks

[american_pie8887]

No: HPFGUIDX 70216

Those are all really good, thought-out points. I have to wonder if 
I've been living under a rock considering I've never heard this 
theory. When I heard the title of the theory, i thought "What the 
heck? NO way" but the scary thing is the more I read of the evidence, 
the more probable it became. So, I think it's POSSIBLE, but a little 
bit far-fetched (but then again JKR had never ceased to surprise me!)

The only problem I have with this theory is the fact that James is in 
Remus's body and that's it. He'd have to work pretty hard to keep 
Remus's personality so no one would be suspicious. Because I mean, 
come on, based on what we've learned of James in OoP, Remus and James 
are almost opposite. And plus, in PoA i always noticed how Remus was 
always fairly nice to Snape and i dont think James could've done 
that. Or, maybe he felt bad about the past and this was his way of 
repaying Snape? Who knows, it's an interesting thought to pursue. I 
know I'd be thrilled if this were all true, but I do love Remus 
Lupin. (if that's his real name !)
~~~Mags