Is there a Major Flaw in OOP?
flussbiber
flussbiber at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 15 09:38:21 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 70472
Well, let me try this again since nobody
responded to my last post. Maybe it has
been discussed and dismissed, but I
would still very much like to know, at
least what other people think about it,
please?
Is it really only me who thinks it is
very odd and doesn't make sense that
the ministry is completely deserted when
Harry and his friends get there? If
the Death Eaters can clear the ministry
so easily, never mind whether it's in
the dead of the night or not, there is
absolutely no reason why Voldemort
shouldn't walk in there and just pick up
the prophecy, no? Was that what the
Order was trying to lure him into? They,
or at least Dumbledore, know that the
prophecy is rather useless to Voldemort
now, except that it tells him clearly
that he has to kill Harry if he wants
to live (ah, doesn't he now?). No big
news. Also, as somebody on this list
pointed out, they could have easily
destroyed the prophecy if they really
didn't want Voldemort to get it.
So ...
Question number 1:
Why is there no security in the ministry - either from officials or
from the Order?
which leads to question number 2:
Why did Voldemort not just go there, unseen and pick up the prophecy?
Question number 3:
Why did Snape need several hours to get worried enough to alarm the
other members of the Order? Also, didn't Sirius get suspicious when
Snape checked on him?
I'm not criticising Rowling, at least not yet, I just cannot
understand this and had hoped that someone in this huge group might
have been able to help me. Thanks.
Flussbiber
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive