Col. Fubster

[hedge2staxy]

No: HPFGUIDX 70515

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Lynx412 at a... wrote:
> jenny from ravenclaw said:
> Okay, I cannot take credit for this idea, but I loved it so I'll 
put
> it out there again.  It could be possible that Harry was not the 
one
> at all who broke Marge's glass in PoA.  It could have been Petunia,
> tapping into her own stores of possible abilities, reacting to the
> fact that her sister-in-law pretty much referred to Lily as a 
bitch (I
> remember being quite shocked the first time I read that scene).
> >>>>>
> 
>        While reading this thread I came up with a totally 
different theory. 
> JKR has said that someone will develop magic late in life, or some 
variant on 
> that phrase. What if the person is Aunt Marge? After all, she 
tells us this is 
> the second time she's broken a glass like this and from her 
comments about the 
> first time Harry was no where near her when it happened.
> 
>        Cheryl the Lynx, who would love to see Uncle Vernon deal 
with a witch 
> for a sister...

Me:
A very interesting idea, especially because it would give Dudley a 
dose of magical ancestry from both sides of his family tree.  I 
still think if Dudley was magical he would have seen the dementors, 
but I'd love to see the scenario of Dudley as wizard!
-hedgehog