Vanishing and Conjuring - how does it work?
Rach
rachrobins at hotmail.com
Wed Jul 16 04:29:27 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 70715
I have been thinking since reading OOP about the limitations of the
wizarding world, and how things cannot be fixed with the wave of a
wand. This led me to wondering how vanishing and conjuring works.
When Bill vanished the scrolls from the table in Sirius' kitchen
where did they go? They obviously go somewhere so they can be
produced again. I'm sure the Order would have needed the scrolls
back. But what about Snape vanishing Harry's Potion. Is this
retrievable? Is there a number of shell-less snails and tail-less
mice floating around somewhere as a result of McGonnagal's vanishing
class?
I have the same confusion about conjuring. We have lots of examples
of adult wizards conjuring objects (plates of sandwiches, table
cloths, squashy purple sleeping bags, chintz armchairs etc) where do
they come from. It is like summoning - you can only conjure something
that already exists that you own. Why can't the Weasleys conjure Ron
pyjamas that are the right length, or dress robes.
Can you only conjure something that you have previously vanished? Is
there some sort of storehouse full of vanished objects from which you
can conjure stuff perhaps? (Okay I don't really believe either of
these, but its all I've got).
Have I missed something in canon that sheds some light on this? I
think I need a copy of the Standard Book of Spells Grade 5!
Rach
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive