Scar doesn't cut it as H=V

[hickengruendler]

No: HPFGUIDX 70839

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Doriane" <delwynmarch at y...> 
wrote:
 
 
> 
> 1. DD is the one that says that the choice was either between Harry 
> or Neville. But I'm getting VERY wary of DD. After all, "as the 
> seventh month dies", or whatever the prophecy says, doesn't 
> necessarily mean *exactly* on the 31st of July. It could mean any 
day 
> at the end of July. So there might have been more than 2 kids. And 
> for all we know, it might even not have been July that year. Maybe 
it 
> was years later. Maybe the kid isn't even born ? Maybe the Prophecy 
> hasn't been fulfilled yet at all ? 

I am pretty sure July 16 years ago was meant. After all, Trelawney 
also said, that the one with the power "approaches", that doesn't 
sound that it will happen 20 years in the future. Also, I am not 
entirely sure, but I think Dumbledore never said that the child has 
to be born July 31th. He only said at the end of July. I am not even 
sure, if it is canon, that Neville is born July 31th. I think it was 
narrowed down to Harry and Neville, because their parents defied 
Voldemort three times.

Hickengruendler