Fw: [HPforGrownups] Re: OOP: what we forget with Sirus and James and Harry /Xmas Decoration in Blacks'

[Koticzka]

No: HPFGUIDX 71140

> --- Koticzka <koticzka at wp.pl> wrote:
> > *****Koticzka's clarification:
> > What I meant was that Snape was rejected by
> > students, colleagues, not by his
> > family, who we know nothing about. I do not find the
> > fact that Snape
> > remembers his parents' argument evidence of a bad
> > relationship between the
> > Snapes. And there is no proof, only an indication in
> > JKR's description, of
> > Snape's possible loneliness at Hogwarts.
>
> Rebecca answered:
> >>It wasn't just an arguement.  My parents argue.  But you won't find my
> mother "cowering."  The indicates fear.  The relationship was obviously
(to
> me, others
> may diasagree) at least verbally abusive.  And Sevearus saw it as a child.
> It is my belief (though there is no proof) that Dad was as abusive to his
> son as he was to his wife.<<
>
> ****Koticzka's comment again:
> Need to use better dictionary... Anyway - I have this impression Snape's
> mother left him somehow. And I am not the only one. As there is no prove,
> that Snape was lonly in his family, which is ny stong belief, I did not
want
> to use it in the discussion as an - hm - argument (the other meaning it
has,
> hasn't it?).
> Yes, I do believe his life was not what any human (Muggle or not)
deserves.
> And I do not feel pity just for Snape - it is anger against all those
> brainless creatures who have no sympathyt in fact. Well - just an ordinary
> reaction and clasic case as a psychologist could say (I am lucku not to
hear
> that comment, I feel rather no need to know to much about myself at the
> moment...) ;)
> I am on Snape's side - objectivly and it is not related to me beeing keen
on
> Snape generaly. Which I admit - I am!
>
>
> Koticzka
> How can you hurt a man who has nothing?
> Give him something broken.
>