[HPforGrownups] Re: First meetings; Poor poor Slytherin at the House Cup

[Random]

No: HPFGUIDX 71563


On Friday, Jul 18, 2003, at 11:45 America/Indianapolis, darrin_burnett 
wrote:
> Oh please. First, if Hagrid had told him about Sirius, it wouldn't 
> have been a
> false absolute, because Hagrid would have told him otherwise. "They 
> are bad
> eggs, except for this one guy, who was a bad egg anyway"

He never said that all slytherins are bad eggs, just that all bad eggs 
are slytherins. and the way he said it "There hasn't been a wizard 
that's gone bad who hasn't been a slytherin" does not allow the 
"exaggeration excuse"

> We have no evidence the Hat wouldn't have done the Gryff thing anyway.

I believe part of his monologue was "If you insist"

--Random832