DD eating at the Dursleys (was:Dumbledore is Hedwig)

[nineve_laguna]

No: HPFGUIDX 71694

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Dan Feeney" <dark30 at v...> 
wrote:
> In CoS, they are late for the feast, have Hedwig with them 
> (terrified, I might add) and see the sorting. So, sorry, the idea 
> doesn't fly.
> 
> dan
**************
I am with you, Dan.
Not only it would be ridiculous to DD to:
1. be kept in a cage at the Dursleys, eating scraps of food, 
2. bring Harry his mail in the Great Hall while DD sits there at the 
staff table,
3. sleep in the owlery, etc...

Dumbledore is a VERY busy man. He is a powerful Legilimens, and 
doesn't need to be an animagus to know what goes on around him. 
Talking of animagi, DD is such a politicaly-correct wizard and so 
well known, that it would be obvious and safe for him to register 
with the MoM as an animagus. I don't see DD "doing a Rita Skeeter" 
and going around unregistered, evesdroping on people. He is SO above 
that!
And last but definitely not least, every single clue that JKR gives 
us makes sense and unravels at the end of the book or follows up as a 
important part afterwards. If, all of a sudden, JKR turned around and 
siad that DD was Hedwig, even with all refutable theories, it 
wouldn't make sense.
Nineve.