Evans family
kuligkutig
vam0609 at aol.com
Thu Jul 24 02:08:51 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 72735
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Allison Hill"
<octaviaempressofmars at h...> wrote:
<sni>
He mentions Lily, "Look what she had fer
> a sister!" He's clearly talking about Petunia as Lily's sister and
not
> Petunia as Harry's aunt. Why would Hagrid have met some random
student's
> Muggle sister?
me :
I don't think Hagrid met Petunia before that night that he delivered
Harry's letter. He said that "Look what she had fer a sister!"
because he just heard Petunia's tirade about the abnormality of Lily
being a witch in the shack on the rock.
> The third mention is at the Mirror of Erised. Harry "saw other
pairs of
> green eyes like his." Remember, he looks like his dad with his
mother's
> eyes. Would non-magical family members, dead or alive, show up in
a magical
> devise like the mirror?
me :
Ah but Dumbledore said the Mirror of Erised doesn't give us truth nor
knowledge. Harry saw the deepest desire of his heart which is his
family and since he has green eyes his idea of what his family looks
like will be like him.
I really like the idea that the Evans are magical just for the reason
that Mark Evans(if he turns out to be related to Harry and Dudley)
will be in Hogwarts the next book and he will learn magic and he can
get back at Dudley for making him a punching bag. making that 2
cousins that Dudley used to beat up that he will be afraid to now.
vampire
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive