I love Hagrid!
darrin_burnett
bard7696 at aol.com
Fri Jul 25 17:35:01 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 73108
Hi Jenny! Hey Talia!
It's important to remember sometimes that we are talking about a
fairy tale, more sophisticated in the ways of teenagers, perhaps,
but a fairy tale nonetheless.
We can't get apparation licenses (Many times recently, have I wished
for one) and we can't have pots and pans scrub themselves. It's
fantasy.
In the vein, Hagrid is the perfect fairy-tale character.
An 11-year-old boy has been abused, mentally and physically and made
to live in a damn cupboard under the stairs. All of a sudden, on his
birthday, a giant man with a Scottish accent and all kinds of neat
things in his pockets comes by, bullies his hated uncle, gives his
hated cousin a pig's tail and whisks the kid away.
It's the stuff of little boys' dreams.
Hagrid, it's important to remember, was Harry's first friend in the
Wizard World, maybe his first friend period.
Yeah, he drinks too much, and yeah, his student-teacher relations
aren't very good (though I continue to maintain that he has improved
tremendously in his ability to manage a classroom and prepare a
curriculum.)
And for all the griping and moaning about Grawp, Hagrid GOT THROUGH
to him. Grawp and Hagrid had a bond and Grawp remembered Hermione.
The man has a knack.
He knows his subject. He's a ferocious fighter and ally and his
loyalty to Dumbledore is without question.
Harry would not be better off with Hagrid dead anymore than he's
better off with Sirius dead. Yeah, Sirius wasn't able to help too
much the last year.
But you know what? No one is better off when their friends die. To
look at it in terms of what Hagrid or Sirius or Ron can give Harry
is extremely cold.
Darrin
-- Anyone up for a Grawp-Hermione SHIP? It would be like Rocky and
Adrian.
"Grawpy!"
"Hermy!"
"Grawpy!"
"Hermy!"
Ok, maybe not.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive