[HPforGrownups] Re: Snape Theories

[ash Leigh]

No: HPFGUIDX 73422

bibphile wrote: 
> Yes.  But being nice and being a good guy aren't
> the same thing.  I've never accused Snape of being nice.
> 
> He could be a bad guy, but I sure hope not.  I like
> the idea that someone can be mean and still be on the 
> right side. I think it fits well in the HP universe too.

 
I agree bibphile, but I think he is motivated by
personal gain more than he is for the "Greater Good". 
I just have a odd feeling about him and the many
references made about him in the books just don't
seem to fit the many theories floating around about
him. I think JKR is very logical and writes in a very
logical manner, I think many times people try and read
to much into it thinking there is some great mystery
to be had when all the time the answer was right there
in front of us in plain black and white, from the top
of my head:

Trelawney -  although she is a flake we found that her
presence as a teacher had some validation with her
predictions.

ashleigh