[HPforGrownups] Re: Sirius - who is right?

[Charlie Moody]

No: HPFGUIDX 73571

On Sunday, July 27, 2003, at 11:33  PM, magicroxx wrote:

> Sirius' death and his life at
> Grimmauld Place has a lot of holes. One of them is when Harry is
> reading about those herbs that make people confuse and cause them to
> be reckless. Harry thinks "Hermione says Sirius has been acting
> reckless" before drifting off to sleep. So Snape's comments
> definitely brought out the recklessness in Sirius. I see no purpose
> for this passage to be mentioned at all, unless its important. It
> also plays into my theory that there is a mole in the order and that
> mole is someone who 'volunteered' to be part of harry's guard.

"Nine raids.  Nine!  And old Mundungus Fletcher tried to put a hex on 
me when I had my back turned...."
    - Arthur Weasley, "Chamber of Secrets", page 38 (US)

And, in tOotP, Mundungus Fletcher IS showing up with 
possibly-questionable ingredients for Fred & George;  and a final note: 
  no-one ever actually *SAW* that load of cauldron he went to see about, 
did they?