Another GOF Flint?

[RSFJenny19 at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 74101

...Are we all going back and rereading the books to find these now? :)

When Sirius writes to Harry in the beginning of the book, he says "they're 
saying he's got Mad-Eye out of retirement", but in the Pensieve scene with 
Karkaroff (which is clearly after LV's downfall, and therefore after Sirius was 
sent to Azkaban) Harry sees Moody with two normal eyes...So why does Sirius call 
him Mad-Eye in GOF???

I suppose it's possible to find a way to explain this one 
away...somehow...but obviously the "Mad-Eye" came from reference to his magical eye, which now 
appears to have only come about after Sirius was in Azkaban...

~Jenny
Who loved reading the series again after reading book 5 many times, but found 
PoA so much more heart-wrenching :::sigh::... we miss you Sirius...