Fawkes and the Order

[Doriane]

No: HPFGUIDX 74167

"balbu84" wrote:

> I am happy to see that i am not the only one to wonder why this 
> order is named "Order of The Phenix". SOme already said that it was 
> due to the fact that the phoenix reburn from its ashes but I am not 
> convinced: The members of the first order could not kno when 
> creating it that it will reburn a second time, for Voldemort second 
> raise.

My opinion too. If the Order had not been called this way the first 
time around, I'd be fine with it. But why ever call it like that the 
first time ? Was it a reference to a previous Order, maybe one DD had 
created while fighting Grindelwald ?

But I'm reminded of what DD told Fudge when Umbridge told them about 
the DA : "DD's army, not Harry Potter's army". So if this is the 
Order of the Phoenix, and not DD's Order, what does it mean ?

> I still wonder what we are going to learn about Fawkes. Is he 
> Godric Gryffindor's phoenix ? Does anyone know how long a phoenix 
> can live, as I haven't got my Fantastic Beasts..

It's probably something like that. But are Fawkes and DD friends (we 
can't say that DD owns Fawkes) because DD is the Headmaster, or for 
some other reason ?

> Amicalement Quentin

Encore un Francais :-) ?

Del