Is Voldie able to conjure a patronus? ... and some other thoughts

dominik_reisner dominik_reisner at yahoo.com
Thu Jul 31 19:18:03 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 74454

Hi, I might be heading in a totally wrong direction, but I couldn`t 
help thinking about it.
I think Voldemort is not able to conjure a Patronus since Lupin 
states "The Patronus is a kind of positive force, a projection of 
the very things that the dementor feeds upon - hope, happiness, the 
desire to survive..." (PoA US version p. 237) 
Aren`t these part of the feelings Dumbledore believes Voldemort is 
incapable of. Now you might say that he can feel happiness, i.e. the 
escape of the Azkaban DEs, but is this true happiness? To me it 
looks like satisfaction, nothing more. 
And secondly, he doubt he would need the patronus charm to ward off 
a dementor, even if they weren´t on his side, since he`s after all 
the second most powerful wizard in the world. 

Also, has anybody of you seen the live reading in the Royal Albert 
Hall. JK says something quite interesting there. She simply states 
does not YET have the power to fight LV. I know this looks stupid, 
but why would she use the word yet instead of he doesn´t have the 
power to fight him. Is this a possible (very weak and desparate) 
hint?

My comment on Dumbledores lifespan. Might it be possible that he is 
able to brew some kind of Phoenix powerup draft to restore his life 
energy? This might be a possible explanation why he chose Fawkes as 
a pet (next to his other extrordinary abilities). One last thought 
on Fawkes: I think that if Dumbledore dies (and I`m sure he will, at 
the beginning of book 7 at the latest), Harry will become fawkes new 
owner, since JK hinted he might get a new pet later on

That`s all for now
Dominik






More information about the HPforGrownups archive