OOP: Audio Clip Theory

[pastafor5]

No: HPFGUIDX 60593

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Gregory Lynn" 
<gregorylynn at a...> wrote:
> Pure conjecture, of course.
> 
> I think Sirius Black is "captured" and the fact kept from Harry to 
prevent him from leaving the Dursleys.  By "captured" I mean that he 
allows himself to be captured at Dumbledore's request (instruction) 
in order to publicize the fact that Voldemort has returned.  Picture 
it, Black and Dumbledore floo themselves to the Leaky Cauldron (or 
some other public place).  Black is taken into custody and Dumbledore 
makes a very public stink about Black being innocent and demanding 
the trial Black never got before.

Me:

You have a great theory here, but I have one small doubt.  Fudge had 
given the dementors permission to administer their "kiss" on Sirius 
when they find him.  And considering how quickly Fudge had the 
dementor kiss Barty Crouch Jr., I don't think he'd have a problem 
doing it to Sirius before taking him into custody, let alone giving 
him a "fair trial."

Still, if there's a way for Dumbledore to keep the dementors away 
from Sirius, you could have something here.  He could possibly use 
Sirius to get inside information from Azkaban, or to work from the 
inside to get rid of the dementors and unite other unjustly 
imprisoned wizards/witches.

pastafor5 (Saturday can't get here fast enough!)