[HPforGrownups] Re: Harry and Snape

[Kurt Douglass]

No: HPFGUIDX 60767

Hels wrote:

>I can't help thinking that Snape's dislike of Harry is something more
>than a crush a long time ago on Lily or a childhood prank. It is too
>deep and bitter. Snape hated Harry from the moment he saw him without
>even giving him a chance. No, IMO there is a reason for Snape to hate
>Harry himself. Could it be that Snape is jealous for some reason? He
>is ambitious and is absolutely furious when he realises Sirius has
>escaped. He is correct in assuming Harry is involved but his fury
>extends further than rule breaking. He cross that an old rival has
>escaped but also that he loses the recognition for saving the trio
>and bringing a supposed DE to trial. Could it be that his hatred of
>Harry is due to the WW not recognising an earlier achievement - one
>for which Harry has unknowingly taken the credit? Was Snape present
>at Godric Hollow at the fall of Voldemort? Was he the real reason why
>Voldemort failed to kill Harry? Did Snape kill Voldemort and prevent
>Harry from being cursed? If so, it would account for Harry's survival
>and Dumbledore's trust. The question would be 'why does the wizarding
>world not know about it'?


Goody theory. I think there is a lot about that night that Voldemort fell 
that Rowling hasn't revealed.

"Kurt"