OOP: Neville & The Prophecy...

bambi_1919 bambi_1919 at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 23 21:38:52 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 62394

Moon said:
> I just finished reading the book last night and correct me if I'm 
> wrong but...  Wasn't it said that the only people that can touch 
the 
> prophecy are the people who it is about, and if so, why was Neville 
> able to touch it?


Actually, it's not that they are the only ones who can hold it...they 
are the only ones who can get it down from the shelf.  After that, 
anyone can get it...thus the Death Eaters showing up after he had 
retrieved it and asking for him to hand it over.  After it's off the 
shelf, it's fair game.  And since LV picked Harry and marked him, the 
prophecy then became definitively about him, as Dumbledore said.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive