OoP: I don't understand some things of Dumbledore

Kirsten Gilson byujava at yahoo.com
Mon Jun 23 22:43:34 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 62422

> DD doesn't really make a big deal about protecting
> the prophecy. He 
> and the order only go to the Department of Mysteries
> to rescue the 
> kids. The other members of the order who run into
> trouble with LV are 
> basicaly pawns, chosen because they aready know that
> LV's back and 
> therefor pose no risk of alerting more people to his
> return. 
> 
> The people who make a big deal about the prophecy
> are Neville and 
> Harry, mainly because they dont know what it says or
> who knows it. DD 
> tells the prophecy to Harry because Harry needs to
> know, if only so 
> that he wont go to drastic measures to find out
> later. DD only cares 
> about it to the extent that it could effect Harry.
> He knew that LV 
> wanted it, and would try to make Harry get it.
> ~Calimora (Who hates the idea of the Last Marauder
> Standing

Sorry if this has been asked before, but how come DD
didn't tell Harry what was going on with his dreams. 
I'm sure Snape must have reported the visions to DD,
and he would then know that Volde was trying to lure
Harry there.  If DD had just told Harry then what the
prophecy was and that Volde was going to try to lure
him there, then why would Harry want to get it?  It
doesn't make sense to me.  

Oh, and how come Dumbledore thought that he could only
tell Harry important information like this at the end
of the year?  Why couldn't he call Harry to his office
in, say, October and let him know something then?  Any
ideas?

Kirsten

__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! DSL - Now only $29.95 per month!
http://sbc.yahoo.com




More information about the HPforGrownups archive