OOP: Dumbledore DIDNT explain everything

[falcongk81]

No: HPFGUIDX 62788

Most likely, we've still got more to learn about Harry's parents.  
Alot of people seem to think that the Potters are descendents of 
Godric Gryffindor.  I'm inclined to believe this.  I'm not sure which 
book this is mentioned in, but it is even stated somewhere that James 
and Lily's house is in "Godric Hollow".  I was quite ticked off at 
Dumbeldore, cause I'm SURE there is more to Harry's story than we 
learned.  Of course, there may be things that he doesn't know, but I 
have to err on the side of caution, and in Dumbledore's case that 
means I would assume that he knows these sorts of things.

It would also make more sense as to why LV chose Harry over Neville.  
If you had to pick one of the two, and you knew that one of them is a 
descendent of Gryff, then you go with that one.  I also can't wait to 
see Neville truly come into his full power.  I'm thoroughly convinced 
that he is stronger than we've seen.  He would almost have to be if 
there is a chance that Neville could be in Harry's shoes.

FalconGK

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, CareALotsClouds at a... wrote:
> If you all think that James neednt have died, why is the whole of 
Harry's 
> family dead.  And Voldemort said to Harry 'You mother needn't of 
died' (I dont 
> remember if this was book 1 or 4?) he couldnt spare her because she 
wouldnt give 
> up Harry.  He would of left her there if she let Harry go.  Since 
he told her 
> to 'step aside'.  I dont think he randomly kills people unless they 
are in 
> his way such as Frank Bryce and that bagshot woman (I have 
completely forgotten 
> her name).  Lily was in his way, and from Harry's flash back with 
Dementors it 
> was quite evident that Voldemort would of spared Lily if she just 
gave up her 
> son.  (not much to ask you know!?) *rolls eyes*
> Why did Voldemort say 'Your Mother neednt of died' if, also, James 
neednt 
> have died.  He would of said 'Your parents neednt of died'.
> 
> 
> [Non-text portions of this message have been removed]