OOP: The MWPP and Snape class/ Classes in general

Kirstini kirst_inn at yahoo.co.uk
Tue Jun 24 13:52:03 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 62856

Darrin wrote:
<snip big bit about Housing MWPP> 
I still feel this way, but I admit I was given pause to find out 
that, assuming Snape was in Slytherin, the Dark Arts classes were 
Gryff and Slyth shared (and Prof. Flitwick was the teacher! 
Although, it is possible that he was just the proctor of the OWL 
exam and the regular teacher was somewhere else.)
That seems a bit bold, don't you think? To put Gryff and Slyth in 
the Dark Arts classes during the rise of Voldemort, which, make no 
 mistake, probably tinged everything about Hogwarts.


Now me (Kirstini):
But that was just the exam, which the entire year takes together -
 "Parkinson, Patil, Patil, Potter" are called out for the first one 
together, and Draco is glaring over at Harry and smashes his 
wineglass. That was either Charms or Transfiguration, neither of 
which the Gryffs have with the Slyths in real class time. Actually, 
I've always found this a bit odd. As the kids begin to take 
electives in third year, surely their classes would change according 
to requirement? But nope. Divination is still all Gryffs, and they 
still take CoMC with the Slyths. Those two are electives, so surely 
there would be a mixed group of all the students in that year who 
were interested? 
I'm beginning to agree with the poster who identified anti-Ravenclaw 
predjudice. 
Oh, and Zacharias Smith? He wasn't a warm and cuddly kinda 
Hufflepuff, was he? And how come we've never heard of him in 
Herbology before?

Kirstini (currently trying for LOON membership, it would seem) 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive