SPOILERS 2 "mistakes"

[Cindy]

No: HPFGUIDX 62913

  Hi all,

      So glad I found people to talk to.. I finished the book before 
everyone else...anyhow



spoilers..







...




First, JKR writes 15 year olds really well. I can remember being 
horrible at that age and after the stress Harry continues to be 
under, it's no wonder he's a little testy. If his behavior had not 
been this way, it would make him a little unbelievable. 

Cho is a little emotional and I knew from the start that she would 
never be serious with Harry. She couldn't handle it. He needs a 
strong woman behind him.. (Ginny, perhaps???) Ginny and Hermione's 
character development pleased me greatly. Although I couldn't help 
wondering if Hermione will stay so "matter of fact" about everything 
when Ron makes his move. 

Two things bothered me which have been brought up in other posts. 
There is no explanation for how Harry got the Maraduers Map back and 
the fact that James Potter was not a prefect but Head Boy?? Maybe 
Lily turned him around and he became prefect 6th year instead of 
Lupin?? 

Anyway, nice to hear all your thoughts. Thought I would share mine.