Muggle Born Wizards and the Law of Secrecy
thomac77
thomac77 at yahoo.com
Tue Jun 24 21:27:16 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 63205
I have had a nagging question in the back of my mind since I
finished OoP
We know that wizards are born of muggle parents (exactly how the
genetics work for that I would love to know!) but presumably (from
Aunt Petunia in Book 1), the parents don't know their child is a
wizard until they receive their letter from Hogwarts in their
eleventh year. Soooo
1. Wouldn't the Muggle parents have a good laugh at the gag
letter from Hogwarts they just received and chuck the letter in the
trash? Or do Muggle parents get a special packet in the mail
explaining about the Wizarding World? However, who is to say that
they would believe such a packet, and wouldn't that packet violate
the Secrecy Laws?
2. Doesn't the very fact that non wizarding families receive a
Hogwarts Letter violate the Secrecy Laws?
3. Does someone from Hogwarts or the Ministry of Magic
personally deliver the letters to Muggle families? So they can
demonstrate the fact that magic actually exists? And if the Muggle
parents still don't believe, do they have to perform a memory charm
on the spot?
4. If muggle parents refuse to believe in magic, do their
children just grow up as muggles and never realize their full
wizarding potential? Do these muggle/wizards still make odd things
happen when they get angry or upset? How does the Ministry handle
magical accidents by these folks?
5. Even assuming that the parents embrace the far-fetched idea
that their child is a wizard, how much about the Wizarding World are
they allowed to know? Hermione's parents show up in Diagon Alley
how do they know how to get there, and wouldn't seeing all that
stuff blow their muggle minds? Are they prohibited, as muggles,
from telling their muggle friends about the WW (what school does my
child attend? Oh..um
uh
)
6. If knowledge is limited to family, who in the family gets to
know? Obviously siblings, since Petunia knew about Lily. What
about grandparents? Aunts and Uncles? Petunia told Vernon all
about it, obviously, but wouldn't that be a breach of secrecy?
We know that Hermione's parents are normal, practical, well adjusted
Muggles, (they are dentists, after all). They receive a letter from
Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry telling them that their
precocious little Hermione is a witch...and off they send her to
school? There must be more to this story.
-Carisa
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive