OOP: re-Didn't harry see his mum die and thestral theory

[silencescreamsatme]

No: HPFGUIDX 64390


Joanna says:

> I think alot of us have been wondering about that...Has JKR made a 
big 
> mistake by saying that Harry only see the thestrals after seeing 
Cedric die? 
> He witnessed his mother die when he was 1 years old , he still 
remembers it 
> well....He was supposed to see the thestrals when he started 
hogwarts...

I say:

Actually, no. He doesn't remember it at all. The only time he ever 
came close to remembering that night was when the dementors got near 
him, and I don't think that counts.

~Silence