OOP: Harry's ban

stardreams04 queenofthecampus at hotmail.com
Thu Jun 26 22:34:03 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 64589

<snip>
 I know that he isn't going to be on the team again, with all 
Voldemort being back and being a walking target. 
<snip>

I'm confused as to why Harry WOULDN'T go back to being the Seeker on 
the Quidditch team. In OotP Fred or George says outright that Harry 
is only banned from flying as long as Umbridge is at Hogwarts. Now 
that she is gone, I'm sure McGonagall or even Dumbledore himself 
would lift the ban. 

I suppose you could say Harry is a "walking target" now, but that 
didn't keep him off the team in year 5. In book 3, when McGonagall 
believed Harry was in danger from Sirius, she  wanted him to stop 
Quidditch practices, but she never says anything of the sort in book 
5. The fact that Voldemort is not officially acknowledged as being 
reborn is no excuse - McGonagall is a member of the Order, and she 
definitely is aware that Voldemort is back. 

Besides, Harry is happiest when he is flying (reread his reaction 
upon leaving the Dursley's house with the Order members). I think he 
is going to need some pleasurable pasttimes in the dark years to come.

I have one last comment to make on Quidditch: is it just me, or does 
JKR seem to be trying to avoid writing about it? Ever since 
Gryffindor won the Quidditch Cup in Book 3, the wizarding sport has 
become less and less important. In GoF, Quidditch matches were 
nonexistent, and in OotP the readers care only about the one 
Quidditch match that Harry plays in. I know there are more dire 
things afoot in the wizarding world...but still, I think it's an 
interesting development considering Quidditch matches are one of the 
biggest forms of inter-House rivalry, which promises to be an 
important issue in the next two books.
 






More information about the HPforGrownups archive