OotP: Sneaks and Spies
julialaming
julialaming at yahoo.com
Fri Jun 27 04:35:29 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 64777
>
> Paige Woods' Reply:
>
> Well, I sincerely doubt that Wormatil was in any kind of group
that needs so much protection, and he probably was not in the Order.
But I'm with you in the whole, "If-you-tell-you'll-get-ugly-spots-on-
your-face" for the order. Though Dumbledore would probably had a
worse thing happen to the person who betrayed the order. Hmm, do we
know anyone who betrayed the order since Wormtail was definity *not*
in the order?
>
> ~Paige Woods~
On page 174 of the US version, Harry states that not only was
wormtail in the picture of the Order, but he was seated between Harry
parents. I think it would have been a very good idea for Dumbledore
to do a Sneak charm on a list of members. It could have saved the
lives of the Potters.
Hermione is a very clever witch, but still nothing compared to
Dumbledore, so why did she think of this protection for DA and
Dumbledore didn't for the Order? Of course he thought he was
protecting them by making Wormtail their Secret Keeper.
And a quick question on a completely different topic. Didn't
anyone notice that Sirius didn't have the Death Eaters mark on his
arm? Even if the MoM didn't know about those till now, couldn't that
have been used to prove his innocence? This has been driving me
nuts.
Julia
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive