OOP: Read 'em and weep (who's dying?) Was: Thoughts on the OOTP

outahand6789 si1verwolf at hotmail.com
Fri Jun 27 10:54:45 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 64848

Don't forget Bellatrix Lestrange...100% odds she's gonna get what's 
coming to her.  and I'd venture 90% that it'll be at the hands of 
Neville Longbottom.  I don't think the odds of Neville dying are as 
high as I thought they'd be while reading OoP.

Odds that McGonnagal is going to die...inversely proportional to 
Dumbledore's...she'll probably take over for him once he's gone.

Pettigrew was mentioned because he informed the DEs that Sirius was 
an Animagus (that's why Malfoy recognized him on the platform 9 
3/4).  If Snape's really doing undercover work for the OP on the DE, 
then he'd defininitely know that Sirius was innocent b/c he'd have 
met Pettigrew.

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "stardreams04" 
<queenofthecampus at h...> wrote:
> In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, <jbenne27 at t...> wrote:
> But who will be gone? Who is going to fall to the wayside in this 
> march?  I'm sure more deaths are to follow but whom? Look how it 
was 
> brought out how mean even the good wizards can be ifthey think they 
> are doing the right thing.  I think the book pointed out many 
things 
> that have been brought out in the 2000 + post that I'm sure
> have been posted.  Would love to hear everyone's thoughts thanks.
> 
>    
>  OK, here are my predictions, glum though they may be:
> > 
> > Dumbledore:
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 6: 50%
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 7: 95%
> 
> Me: No arguments here. I was expecting him to bite the proverbial 
> dust in book 5, to tell you the truth.
> 
> > Harry:
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 7: 70%
> 
> Me: Not going to touch that whole depressing theory right now...
> 
> > Snape:
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 6: 60%
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 7: 80%
> 
> Me: I might put the percentages for Snape a little lower. Call it a 
> hunch, but I think he'll still be around in the end. I know he's in 
a 
> VERY dangerous line of work, but I think it would be extremely 
ironic 
> if all the Marauders died (though I'm undecided on the fate of 
Lupin)
> and Snape was the only one left standing.
> 
> > Lupin:
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 6: 75%
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 7: 95%
> 
> Me: Would JKR kill off ALL the Marauders? Lupin currently the only 
> one with the slightest possibility of seeing a happy ending.
> 
> > Lucius:
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 6: 35%
> > Likelihood he'll be dead by the end of book 7: 85%
> 
> Me: At first I was surprised - ONLY 85%? Then I realized: A lot of 
> Death Eaters are going to die, but it would be pretty unrealistic 
for 
> ALL of them to get snuffed. I favor Lucius being locked in prison 
for 
> a while - he better not weasel his way out of punishment this time!
> 
> > Ron/Hermione:
> > Likelihood one of the two will be dead by the end of book 6: 50%
> > Likelihood one of the two will be dead by the end of book 7: 80%
> 
> Me: Of the two, I think Ron has a higher likelihood of dying. 
> Hermione is the lead female role in the book, and I don't think JKR 
> would want to kill off the character whom she has said several 
times 
> is very similar to herself.
> 
> ...
>  
> > Dursleys:
> > Likelihood that at least one Dursley will die by the end of book 
7: 
> > 100%
> 
> Me: 100% agreement here. And this raises an interesting scenario: 
If 
> Voldemort kills them personally, then Harry would most likely see 
> them die through Voldemort's eyes - would essentially feel as if he 
> were the one casting the AK. What kind of dark guilt trip would 
this 
> put Harry on?
>   
> > Pettigrew:
> > Likelihood he will be dead by the end of book 6: 80%
> > Likelihood he will be dead by the end of book 7: 100%
> 
> Me: ~outraged~ Why wasn't he mentioned much at all in OotP? It was 
as 
> if he dropped off the face of the earth.
> 
> ~stardreams






More information about the HPforGrownups archive