OOP: Wands and smelting sticks
saintbacchus
saintbacchus at yahoo.com
Fri Jun 27 18:11:34 UTC 2003
No: HPFGUIDX 65041
(Also repeating because of the lacking header. Sorry about that, and
thanks to the ops for the correction!)
The Smelting Stick is sanctioned by the school, and that makes a big
difference. We're invited to laugh at it, because it's Uncle
Vernon's idea of higher education. Students are encouraged to use
the Smelting Stick, so who could blame them if they did?
On the other hand, Hogwarts subscribes to no such theory. If Sirius
and James had been caught they would've been punished. So they knew
what they were doing was wrong, even if only by school policy. I
think that makes a difference.
Regardless of school policy, bullying is bullying. Until I get
further evidence, I'm considering Sirius every bit as bad as Dudley.
--Anna
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive