OOP: WAS:(Sirius) A person is more .. Now:Spy

[parrat74]

No: HPFGUIDX 65200

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Debbie" <debmclain at y...> wrote:


>  Me:
> Personally, I thought immediately that Tonk is a spy for Voldemort. 
> She's klutzy - like she's covering up. Really. Another one of those 
> JK surprises. Why would Voldy want her - she's such a spaz/klutz? 
> Hem, hem.... (God, I hated that!) What about Quirrel and 
> his "stutter"? It was just an act. Tonk's could be too. She was so 
> nice, growing nose hairs during dinner for the girls...again, 
making 
> us think one thing instead of the truth.
> 
> I think Tonk will end up being a spy. She only stunned Lucius and 
> then was out cold for a while herself. Why not something stronger 
on 
> Lucius if she's really an auror? Oh, my poor Lucius! I was really 
> hoping for him to get more meat in the septology (become MOM) but 
> doesn't look like it now that he's in jail. :-( At least he got 
more 
> face time than Draco (sad, as that is).
> 
> -Debbie

I haven't seen anyone bring this up about Tonks being a spy - on pg. 
52 of the US version, Tonks tells Harry she only qualified as an 
Auror a year ago.  When Harry meets with McGonagall for career 
counseling on page 662, McGonagall tells him "I don't think anybody 
had been taken on (as an Auror) in the last three years."  Maybe 
McGonagall isn't up to speed on Auror admissions, but I found it 
interesting.