FOUND IT: Charlie's No. 2

[Amy Z]

No: HPFGUIDX 53491

Steve quoted:

> > PoA; Am. PB., Chapter 'Quidditch Final', Pg 301 - "Gryffindor 
hadn't
> > won the Quiiditch Cup since the legendary Charlie Weasley (Ron's
> > second oldest brother) have been Seeker."

[Ed. note:  "have been Seeker"?]

and added:

> > This would confirm that indeed Bill is the oldest brother.

Amanda wrote:

> It would confirm only that he is indeed the oldest brother *now,* 
at the
> moment. I happen to be a "missing Weasley child" adherent (and, 
relatedly, a
> "seventh-son Ron" follower), and so I must devil's advocate and 
point this
> out.

Most missing-Weasley/seventh-son adherents buttress their 
speculations with the fact that there is a large gap between Charlie 
and Percy, however.  If there was a brother in that spot, his death 
wouldn't have changed Bill's or Charlie's position.

Amy Z

--------------------------------------------------------
"This is the weirdest thing we've ever done," Harry said 
fervently.  -PA
--------------------------------------------------------