Harry's divination exam (was: Re: Lily's protection)

[redandgoldlion]

No: HPFGUIDX 53859

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "finwitch" <finwitch at y...> 
wrote:
>... 
> All this talk about Harry having Lily's eyes -- and Harry *did* 
> happen to see Buckbeak flying free - a *true* vision, not to 
mention 
> his past/present-dreams, as well as the cryptic ones that show 
future 
> and act as a warning...
>  
> -- Finwitch
    I was just wondering about your comment that Harry saw Buckbeak 
fly free. I know he told Trelawney he saw that, but I've always had 
the impression that he at least thought he made it up. Doesn't he say 
something to the effect of remembering that Ron had made up 
his "prediction" when he doesn't see anything? And then he goes on to 
tell his "prediction." Personally, I *do* feel he really "saw" it, 
but he just assumed he was making it up. I suppose he could have 
truly made it up as well; you know, saying that to sort of comfort 
himself or even to burst Trelawney's little bubble of excitement she 
gets when she *sees* something terrible happening. ;-)
   Please correct me if I'm way off base. Any more thoughts? 
     ~redandgoldlion~