[HPforGrownups] Harry's divination exam (was: Re: Lily's protection)

[iluvgahan]

No: HPFGUIDX 53868


--- redandgoldlion wrote:

> I know he told Trelawney he saw that, but I've
> always had the impression that he at least thought he
> made it up.
  
<snip>

> Personally, I *do* feel he really "saw" it, but he just 
> assumed he was making it up. I suppose he could have 
> truly made it up as well; you know, saying that to sort
> of comfort himself or even to burst Trelawney's little
> bubble of excitement she gets when she *sees* something 
> terrible happening. 

Now me:

I always had the impression that he just made that
prediction up because he couldn't really see anything.  But
I don't think he really did "see" that. IIRC Trelawney
seemed to be egging him on asking him if he was sure he
didn't see anything terrible like Buckbeak being beheaded,
or something to that effect ( sorry, I don't have the book
with me right now) and I got the impression that he said no
to spite her in a way, or like redandgoldlion said, to
comfort himself. Just my thought :)

BTW I've been lurking for awhile but I really love reading
all your thoughts, so I thought I'd introduce myself :)





=====
Christina "I solemnly swear that I am up to no good."

__________________________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Web Hosting - establish your business online
http://webhosting.yahoo.com