Neville/Memory Charms

[Cindy C.]

No: HPFGUIDX 56955

 
Grindieloe wrote:

> Wouldn't it just serve Malfoy right if Neville's memory charm 
>could somehow be broken, without harming Neville of course, and 
>Neville is then able to reveal that Lucious Malfoy was also 
>responsible for torturing the Longbottoms? Hmmm... Lucious 
>certainly does have a good reason for giving large sums of money to 
>St.Mungos.

Ooooh, Lucius Malfoy as the Root Of All Evil, huh?  Now, where are 
Eileen and Elkins when I need them?

Never mind.  

<rolls up sleeves>

We know that Mr. and Mrs. Lestrange probably participated in the 
Longbottoms' torture, and young Barty Crouch was probably there 
too.  That leaves us with the mysterious fourth man in the Pensieve.

Could that fourth man have been Lucius Malfoy?  Oh, I would dearly 
love for this theory to work, but alas, I can't make the pieces 
fit.  I think Harry would have recognized Lucius Malfoy had he been 
one of the Pensieve Four defendants.

So why *does* Lucius Malfoy give large sums to St. Mungos, though?  
I mean, why *St. Mungos,* of all places?  Makes me wonder if OoP 
will have St. Mungos as one of the primary settings . . .   Makes me 
wonder if Neville's frequent visits there will be important . . .   
Makes me wonder about a certain *toad* . . . 

Cindy -- still convinced Mundungus Fletcher is a doctor at St. Mungos