Murder she wrote...

grace701 grace701 at yahoo.com
Wed May 7 18:55:05 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 57240

Amy wrote:
 
> Prof. S. Snape – Hmm, difficult, difficult.  So many paths to 
> choose.  There are those who could argue that he's already dead, 
> being a vampire or the fact that he may be bitten in the future.  
> Being eaten by a werewolf also has a nice feel to it but 
> unfortunately being by far the most over emotional character in 
> the novel I am pretty sure that Prof. Snape is going to find 
> himself missing a soul in the near future.  Think of the emotion 
> in the scene when the man who had more baggage than your usual 
> airport turns to face Harry and doesn't see Lily's eyes or James's 
> hair or Voldemorts scar, just a boy.  Oh and he "dies" never 
> forgiving or being forgiving.

This is very Bangsty.  I like it.  I would actually love to see some 
sort of apology from Snape to Harry and vice versa, or an 
understanding of some sort, either before he dies or while he's 
dying.  I will be crying my eyes out, as well.


> Denis Creevy – Many readers feel that this tiny boy has been 
> written in just to be killed off, and hopefully turn his brother 
> against Harry and the wizarding world in general.  So I'm afraid I 
> have this mousy little boy filled under becoming a midnight, 
> moonlit snack for a certain werewolf.  Which leads us too


Something needs to be done with the Creeveys in general, they're 
very annoying.  

 
> Prof. R. J. Lupin – After the death of Creevy two I'm afraid that 
> Prof. Lupin who teeters so close to the edge may very well fall 
> off.  But how will the werewolf bump himself off?  There is always 
> Harry walking into a deserted classroom to find Remus hanging on a 
> self-made noose but I  would prefer to see him (not literally of 
> course) slit his wrists in a bath of warm water.
> Oh, and Sirius can walk in and see the aftermath.

All I can do is bow my head and cry because yes I can picture this 
happening.  Lupin will forget to take his wolfsbane potion and 
attack someone.  I'd prefer it'd be someone we know, they not die, 
but he realizes he has to lock himself up.  I still want him around, 
I don't to see Lupin die.

<snip>

> Hermione Granger – Well if she does die it is going to be through 
> the incompetence of forgetting she's a witch.  Even if she doesn't 
> die she is probably going to be seriously wounded in the same 
> reasoning.


Hermione's going to die a horrible death and at the hands of Lucius 
because we all know how much he loves Mudbloods.

<snip> 
 
> Ron Weasly – Yes, there is just no escaping all this foreshadowing 
> warnings that the boy is going to sacrifice himself.

Yes, I think that is a bit obvious.  I see him sacrificing himself 
for Harry and/or Hermione.

 
>Murder? – And the next victim of murder in the Potterverse?  Well 
>I'm not too sure of this but what I am sure of is that the next 
>burst of  green light that is used to kill some one, it wont be the 
>victim that bangs, but the murderer.  Harry Potter.

Wow, I never really thought Harry would murder someone, besides 
Voldemort of course, but now you have me thinking that Harry could.  
Who could Harry kill?  Hmmmm...

Great job on this Amy!  You have me seeing character deaths in 
different views now. So you think that the next murder will be by 
Harry?  This would mean that it *could* happen in book 5 and it is 
another way for Harry to examine death closely because he is the 
cause of it.  Hhmmmmm....


Greicy





More information about the HPforGrownups archive