Evil!Molly / Evil!Lupin / SLURP

[maria_kirilenko]

No: HPFGUIDX 57936

Maria Alena, now, replying to those Molly-loves-her-children posts:

Might I step in to say that a mother can love her children and still 
be evil? That's not beyond the realm of possibility, you know. 

This is reminiscent of those arguments against Evil!Lupin that go 
something like this:

"Well, if Lupin is evil, why does he not like turning into a 
werewolf? He should enjoy killing people then."

Being evil and disliking violence and loss of self-control are not 
mutually exclusive.

Kelly asked:
> Why is buying green robes considered as evil?  

Ah, it is the colour of Slytherin, the House of Evil Wizards. Ask 
Darrin, he'll tell you. <g>

Kelly again:
> McGonagall wears green robes as well, and I think Arthur was even
> described as wearing green. Personally, I've wondered for a little 
> bit if there is some significance in the color of a witch or 
> wizard's robe color?

Actually, the only reason I brought Evil!Molly up was because I had 
suddenly remembered the Evil!McGonagall post (and it made such a 
coherent argument), which listed the fact that she wears green robes 
as evidence of her evilness. Molly, too, seems to like the colour 
green, and we must be consistent, mustn't we? 

We must also keep in mind that those two MOM wizards who drove Harry 
et al to King's Cross in PoA also wore green. They were evil as well.

Pippin wrote:

> Lupin *could* have used that argument himself, but he doesn't. 
> ""Not if he thought I was the spy. I assume that's why you didn't 
> tell me?" he said casually..." If there's one thing we know about 
> Lupin, it's that he's casual about important stuff. He  really
> wants to find out if he was suspected. Maybe he's just looking for 
> an opportunity to confess that he himself suspected Sirius. Or not.

What do *you* make of that phrase? How does it tie in with Evil!
Lupin? What do you mean, "Or not?" I hope I'm not being thick here.

Lupin *is* casual about important stuff, true. But I don't think they 
were going to start a long talk about why, exactly, they suspected 
each other of being spies in front of the children. 

About SLURP:

Amy, I want to join SLURP, but only if Unsullied Reputation means 
that Lupin's not a DE. If that also means that he's perfect, I can't. 
Sorry.

Maria Alena
   ---how's Green Robes for a band name?