Evil!Molly

[maria_kirilenko]

No: HPFGUIDX 57939

Lorrie wrote:
> One more thing: Evil Molly. THAT is insidious! And I don't know 
> which is worse, that you people have thought of this, or that it
> might be true.

Maria Alena:

Aw, Lorrie, it's fun! I don't think there's been a character who 
hadn't been accused of being evil at some point in time, so why 
should Molly be an exception? Besides, you should know that the 
term "Evil" is used to mean lots of different things here. 

"We people" have thought of many things. Well, *I* haven't thought of 
many, but there are lots of theories around, and some of them are 
just terrible. "So EWWWer It's In the SEWWWer" is one. The Harry is 
Voldemort and Harry is Voldemort's father make me react pretty much 
the same way. 

Ever So Evil (ESE), for instance, means that the person in question 
is a Death Eater or an active Voldemort supporter. 

Evil can also mean "capable of betrayal." The first time I 
participated in an Evil!Lupin discussion, in December - shortly after 
I joined, we shifted from discussing ESE!Lupin to Perfidious!Lupin. 
Both involved calling Lupin evil.

Evil!Molly doesn't mean that she has the Dark Mark or goes around 
murdering people. She can pass on information a la Ludo Bagman (or 
not pass on information, a la Lupin) and still be called evil.

Pippin, I'm having fun discussing ESE!Lupin now, do you know? I'm in 
shock. But only ESE. Not perfidious.

Maria Alena

To find out about the mentioned theories, go to 
http://www.hpfgu.org.uk/faq/hypotheticalley.html