Time Travel Paradoces and Adopted!harry...

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 58033

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Koticzka" <koticzka at w...> 
wrote:
> Was Buckbeak killed at first in PoA? I had an impression he was 
actually decapitated. And afterwards the deer appears.
> 
> Note: If time traveling works consequently - Hippogriff should be 
dead and there should be no deer at the first version of events.
> OR Hippogriff should be spared nad deer should appear.
> Another mistake? - I suppose so. But I have to check it up

Valky (me);
Ok, Koticzka. You really lost me after that. I am fascinated by your 
argument that the time line that happens first is one unaffected by 
the successive loop. But I just cannot quite grasp all the points 
that you have made. Please reiterate for the dummies like me. :P