The Trelawney Prediction

M.Clifford valkyrievixen at yahoo.com
Mon May 19 11:30:27 UTC 2003


No: HPFGUIDX 58171

Hi Everyone,
I posted this comment previously this week. In deep obscurity. Which 
I suppose is the reason it has generated no responses.
THat is of course assuming that the entire list hasn't decided to 
never reply to my posts again :P 

I have noticed that something strange is generally accepted in the 
theories that I have read. Many are satisfied with the concept that 
Trelawneys *First True Prediction* was the fall of Voldemort. 

In contrast I would like to question this complacency among fans. 
JK has duped me too many times to rest my laurels on that simplistic 
and logical conclusion.

I would like to hear suggestions from the posting list on what 
Trelawneys "other" premonition was. 

I haven't got any theories myself. What I would like to contribute is 
some canon to ponder. 
Professor Trelawney is not exactly noted for *cheerful* visions. 
Some may disagree but I do believe that the defeat of the ominous 
Dark Lord is a little too positive a prediction for Trelawney. 
Doom and perdition are her watermark so what chance that she could 
depart so fully from her usual and be the bearer of news that would 
cause revelling in the streets. 

Any replies?
Valky
   





More information about the HPforGrownups archive