JKR's writing vs story, maybe a little OOP (but nothing factual)

[olivierfouquet2000]

No: HPFGUIDX 58334

I can tell you what really striked me as incredibly good in JKR wrinting style especially 
easily because I was skeptic about the Harry Potter phenomena before someone 
forced a copy in my hands. I was greatly impressed by the ability she has to deliver 
powerful psychological message through magical metaphors. 

For instance, I believe Dobby is a vivid portray of a disturbed or abused child. He is 
self-punishing, tries to relate to others in a clumsy way, dressed with horrible 
clothes, his face looks like the face of a child in pain, he is certainly abused and 
finally freed when he receives a present. MWPP turned animagi on their fifth year, this 
is to say when they turned sixteen, a great way to symbolise puberty. The moving 
stairs of Hogwarts too are a good idea, in fact I swear I had the impression that the 
stairs of my Junior High School were moving when I was in first year. I could go on 
and on, practically every significant memory I have of that period of my life found an 
echo in HP.

When I reread the whole series, I also had the impression that each book had a 
specific psychological meaning. The first is about the fear of being not up to, the 
second could be about defiance (as suddenly Harry is seen as a danger), PoA is about 
overreacting as was pointed out by Pippin and in my opinion GoF is about the danger 
of getting too involved in something, to be obsessed (the Quidditch champions are 
obsessed with winning ant turn brutal, Moody is obsessed with fighting dark wizards, 
Bagman is obsessed with gambling, Barty Crouch is obsessed with Voldemort, Percy 
with his boss...)

It has be  pointed out that Harry has not yet failed. I think that this could very well be 
the theme of OOP. Not only Harry but all the good character will in my opinion 
experience failure : Ron could turn out to be a poor Quidditch player, Dumbledore 
will make a mistake...Harry's failure will probably be related to the main plot, I think 
he will fail to protect someone who will die. As for Hermione, I think she will remain 
the brightest student but could very possibly fail due to SPEW. After all, it seems that 
for the time being House elves are rather suspicious to SPEW, so Hermione could 
temporarily be the cause of a worsening of the relations between House elves and 
wizards.

Forgive me for my poor english, as it is not my native language
June 21st rules.

Olivier