[HPforGrownups] Death of One of the Trio? / Re: Lily and the deal with the devil

[Koticzka]

No: HPFGUIDX 58802

SnapesSlytherin wrote:
>>What if that's how one of the Trio dies?  (snip) It could happen anytime
between OoP and Book Seven...but I think if one of them dies it will be
later than OoP.<<

***Koticzka's opinion:
No canon for this, but all three of them are needed:
Strategy=Ron
Cleverness / Knowledge = Hermione
Bravery plus Leadership = Harry.
These elements, connected by friendship, will be necessary to fight
Voldemort.  I'd be willing to bet on it... would consider a bet...
Maybe...perhaps.

Oryomai wrote:
>>Okay, let's say, for the sake of this, that Snape was in love with Lily.
He finds out that the Dark Lord wants to kill the Potters.  Snape goes to
Lily and says that they're marked for death.  Lily goes to the Dark Lord and
says that, in exchange for Harry's/her life, she'll give him James.
*shrugs* She's Desperate!Lily.  She doesn't know he'll keep his word, but
she figures that at least she's trying to save her son.  Or something like
that.<<

***Koticzka's rambling/mumbling
I suggested an earlier bargain - something that was arranged in advance,
that would save Harry's life later on, in exchange for someone else's life
(see "Who's whose Heir", I believe).

Koticzka
How can you hurt a man who has nothing?
Give him something broken.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]